"How The World Sees Russia"

Issue #25: 09/15/2018

From the Publisher:

This week’s Rossiya Scan is one where we delve on topics of foreign policy and commerce.  Russia is still winning diplomatic battles around the world and finding creative ways to better their economic situation with new Asian partners.

We begin this issue by looking at the latest Russian moves in Africa. Russia is solidifying its position in the Central African Republic (CAR), despite the fact that its moves grew immensely obvious after the death of 3 Russian journalists investigating the work of the Wagner Group. The latter is a controversial private military agency with alleged close ties to the Kremlin. However, Russia has now ventured elsewhere in Africa, and is obtaining obvious returns from their efforts.  

Early this month, Russia announced that it will be a building a logistics base in the horn of Africa, specifically in Eritrea. This is an area that already has the presence of several powerful foreign countries, both militarily and economically. Hence, the fight for influence in this African region is likely to heat up with Russia’s presence.

China and Russia have a long history of collaboration, but also complications. With the Russian shift to the east, we look deeper into this relationship, and discuss what makes it work, and what doesn’t.

We then move on to a joint Chinese venture by Alibaba, and three Russian entities. This collaboration is likely to create a worthwhile service for Russia, and also have non-market ramifications. The Sino-Russian alliance is likely to be further solidified from a commercial standpoint as a result of this collaboration.

Finally, we visit the latest from the Skripal affair, and try to make further sense of this ongoing conflict between the UK and Russia.

-Rossiya Scan

Russia Consolidates in Africa

It’s official. At least in name and intention.

Russia will be building a logistics base in Eritrea, which would in turn provide it with access to the Red Sea. No timeline was provided for the project, but it’s another sign that Moscow is spreading its wings in Africa, and has now entered its competitive horn. Neighboring Djibouti for instance already hosts a series of foreign bases, including U.S, Chinese and European.

In issue #10, #12 and #20 Rossiya Scan took an in depth look at Russia’s ongoing involvement in Africa. Specifically, the Central African Republic (CAR), a place where they have come to the aid of a battered regime that was abandoned by its former Western allies (France and the U.S).  

Faustin Archange-Touadera, President of CAR, asked Russia for help to secure the existence of his government, which still only controls 20 percent of the country. Russia delivered, and sent various military professionals plus advisors, which have helped consolidate the Touadera government. Last August, Russia’s quiet approach and successful expansion in the heart of Africa was for the first time all over the news. The death of three journalists working on a documentary about the Wagner Group, a Russian private military contractor, and their work in CAR put a spotlight on the Kremlin’s activities in this part of the world.

This spotlight, we speculated, was perhaps likely to make things more difficult for Russia in the region, as it would place it at the center of global attention, and shatter its quiet and efficient expansive approach. Perhaps, it would even lead to an interest in the area again by both the U.S and France. A month into the death of the journalists, and Russia’s presence has apparently been further solidified in the CAR.

“In January this year we got word the Russians were training the president’s security forces in Berengo in [the former CAR dictator Jean-Bédel] Bokassa’s old palace there,” said an unnamed international official who has been monitoring Russian activity in the CAR, according The Guardian. “It went from rumors on social media to a sizable Russian presence at an incredible speed”

With CAR Russia seems to have found a niche, and a strategy that it is working as far as gaining influence in African states. Much like we mentioned in previous issues, Russia is gaining favor through their resolve to assist African governments with military support. Something that these governments see a safety net to their existence. In exchange, Russia attains rich mineral rights.

 “[Russia] can’t offer consumer goods like China but what it can offer is arms and occasional debt relief either in exchange for an arms deal or the rights to explore and drill for hydrocarbons or other extractables,” said Paul Stronski, of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace in an interview with The Guardian. “[Russia] is trying to find a niche where they can be competitive. The niche they really own is arms.”

The strategy is being carried out at the highest levels.  Senior officials, such as Sergei Lavrov, Russia’s foreign minister, and Valentina Matviyenko, chairwoman of the Russian federation council, have both spearheaded military cooperation deals with many African states.

Lavrov, for instance, has had several high-profile visits to various countries. Including, Namibia, Mozambique, Angola, Zimbabwe and Ethiopia.  In these trips, Lavrov managed to obtain various agreements for Russia, in the realm of mineral exploration, preferred economic zones and military cooperation.

With Eritrea, however, Russia has entered a new area that is deemed strategically important by many other non-African parties. The fight for influence in this part of Africa is thus on, and will likely be harder to obtain than in the central African area of the continent. That being said, Russia seems to have found a way of entering this competitive portion of Africa without much opposition.

Of course, Russia’s decision to go through Eritrea, which has been gradually opening up after a decade of isolation, was certainly an approach we are familiar with. Russia is willing to talk to anyone, no matter their record or controversy, in order to obtain what it needs.

A flexible approach that is a keystone to their successful realpoltik foreign policy strategy. We will keep a close watch on this outpost, to see if this presence leads to a worthwhile yield for Russia.

Read more:

"Russia's Scramble for Influence in Africa Catches Western Official's Off-Guard," by Peter Beaumont for The Guardian. 

"Russia is the Latest World Power Eyeing the Horn of Africa," by Abdi Latif Dahir for Quartz. 

"Russia's Pivoting to the Horn of Africa Via Eritrea and the UAE," by Andrew Korybko for the Oriental Review. 

Picture

The Sino-Russia Alliance: Can it Last?

China and Russia share 4.209 km of borders, a large stretch that inevitably leads to mutual apprehension. The Soviet Union at the height of its power supported both the Guomindang and the Chinese communist party, leading to “the treaty of friendship” in 1949 between the two communist nations. Nonetheless, Mao Zedong felt disregarded and undermined by Joseph Stalin. Following Stalin’s death, and with Nikita Khrushchev’s rise to power, ensuing a “peaceful coexistence” policy towards the West; created a feeling of animosity within China.

In 1968, China and Russia were at the brink of war (concentrating 1.5MM troops on the borders, and with Soviet leadership even considering the use of nuclear weapons against its former ally) culminating in a series of Skirmishes in Xinjiang which led to 350 – 700 deaths (mostly Chinese), without any further a due.

Today the roles have changed (China is considered to have a better overall position than Russia), and even though the Kremlin’s global foreign policy successes cannot be disregarded, Russia could potentially become the junior partner in all matters of the Sino – Russian alliance.

The enemy of my enemy is my friend, says a proverb dating back to 4th century BC, which reflects on how little  human behavior has changed when working towards a common threat. Sino-Russia relations are following this rule to the dot, nonetheless Western sanctions on Russia and their alignment to hinder Chinese economic growth, are helping cement a very daring alliance to counterbalance Western influence. This relationship reaffirms itself, when on the 11th and 12th of September Chinese President Xi Jinping participated for the first time in the Eastern Economic Forum of Vladivostok. 

The two countries have long supported each other at the United Nations. For example, China has never said much on Russia’s takeover of Crimea, and they've both worked closely on the North Korea crisis. China has also not been critical of Russia's role in Syria; and recently it has remained mostly silent with the accusations of Russia in the alleged poisoning in the UK, of former Russian double agent Sergei Skripal.

Due to all the sanctions imposed on Russia, and the trade war between China and the U.S., these countries geopolitical, and economic interests are aligning in various aspects. Trade between China and Russia in the first half of the year has soared 50% and is expected to reach $100 billion by the end of 2018. Most importantly, via China, Russia is capable of replacing Western lenders and finding other financial and technological resources to fulfill several Russian energy projects, indirectly helping China strategically secure a steady supply of liquified natural gas (LNG) for the future.

In Rossiya Scan, we would like to highlight strategically how China wins, and Russia wins, but a bit less on the long run. Firstly, China is financing one of the most important LNG projects above the Artic circle carried out by Novatek (MCX:NVTK) in Yamal; positioning itself in the Artic for future resource supply, whilst simultaneously buying ports in the region, to benefit from shipping routes. Potentially undermining Russia’s influence, as it increasingly becomes a more competitive hotspot.

Secondly, Russia is supplying many high-tech weapons to China. Moscow is happy to cash in on weapons sales to China under Western sanctions. However, this is a knife with two edges, as China mostly manufactures, rather than produces military equipment.

Notwithstanding, it has managed to produce 5th generation fighter jets and continues to learn and acquire technology to build on these products, with the aim to become a major seller of military equipment. This would substantially decrease Russian weapon sales to China, at the same time Russian market share in Asia would gradually decline, as China via its economic enveloping of the region would impose nations to buy its weapons once they reach the level of performance of its competitors, such as Russia.

It’s like when you are playing a game of risk, stuck in the middle between two countries and concentrating your forces on the opposite side (in this case Western Europe), knowing that your ally will probably make a move, once he doesn’t need you anymore. In the end, Sino-Russian relations are predicated on the old Maoist adage “If you don’t attack me, I won’t attack you” (人不犯我,我不犯人). Their self-interest given the circumstances, does not necessarily make them allies for the long haul.

Read more:

“China says relations with Russia at 'best level in history,” by Ben Westcott for CNN

“China’s Stakes in the Russian Arctic,” by Nadezhda Filimonova and Svetlana Krivokhizh for The Diplomat.

“Cooperation and Competition: Russia and China in Central Asia, the Russian Far East, and the Arctic,” by Paul Stronski for Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

“SINO-SOVIET RELATIONS,” by Alpha History.  

Picture

The Push East Continues

As we stated last week, Chinese giant Alibaba (NYSE:BABA) is working on a joint venture in Russia. This week, the group signed an agreement with MegaFon (MCX:MFON), Mail.Ru (LSE:MAIL) and the Russian Sovereign Investment Fund.

Is this a sign to the U.S,  that Russian businesses can do business without them?

These firms moreover operate solely in Russia. By partnering with a major Chinese/International actor like Alibaba they attain credibility, which allows them to grow even further by offering additional services. As it was seen with the case of Uber in Russia, U.S firms tend to have difficulties entering be it the Chinese or Russian markets. Two markets where people still prefer to pick “national” giants. For instance, Yandex (MCX:YNDX) is the big fish of car-service apps in Russia, and are the senior partner in their joint operation with Uber. 

This is partially the reason why U.S based internet giant Amazon (NASDAQ: AMAZN) has been unable to get a strong foothold in the Russian market, and why perhaps Alibaba sought this joint-venture.  For it would enable it, by leveraging on the reputation of the other two firms to develop itself successfully in Russia. 

This seems to be a new step towards Russia’s rush eastward, in order to counteract the West’s frostiness. Now the question here is, does the world and more precisely the U.S, want better and closer Sino-Russian relations? Do they want such a polarization? U.S President Donald Trump’s erratic leadership, as well as his continuous sanctioning and trade war with China is unbalancing the world economic stage.

Certes, Trump's actions might prove to be to the benefit of U.S companies, but they are also damaging every other supposed allied nation. The fact is, this is likely to make countries walk away from the U.S. over time. Push them to make their own alliances, and start working towards a world where there is a weaker U.S presence. Of course, we are still far from such a place. U.S economic, political and cultural influence around the world remains too entrenched to be properly challenged. But it’s precisely with such actions that the seeds of a new world order can begin to bear fruit with time.

Finally, we believe this joint venture is likely to be successful. Both Russia and China have plenty of experience carrying these out. This is not their first deal of this kind, and firms from both countries have already found success with this approach.  This is also likely to further strengthen the Sino-Russian alliance.

Read more:

"Alibaba To Setup Online Retail Service in Russia," by Max Seddon for the Financial Times. 

"Alibaba Sets Up $2 Billion Russian Venture With Kremlin Help," by Ilya Khrennikov and Dina Khrennikova for Bloomberg. 

"Alibaba Goes Big on Russia with Joint Venture Focused on Gaming, Shopping and More," by Jon Russell for TechCrunch. 

"Alibaba Teams Up with Russian Tech Giant," by Anatoly Kurmanaev and Stu Woo for the Wall Street Journal. 

"Alibaba Takes Joint Venture Route to Russia Expansion," by Polina Nikolskaya and Vladimir Soldatkin for Reuters. 

Picture

Turning Point: Hit or No Hit?

If we believe what German statesman Otto Von Bismarck said: “Never believe anything in politics until it has been formerly denied.” Then we could assume that the two people the UK is suspecting of leading the operation in Salisbury against former-spy Sergei Skripal and his daughter are in fact agents of the GRU. Yet again, doesn’t it seem opportune? The UK seems to have new information concerning the attack each time Brexit negotiations are in a tough spot.

The two alleged perpetrators of the "failed" hit, contacted the Russian press in order to give an interview. This occurred hours after Russian President Vladimir Putin stated that they were civilians and in no way linked to the security services. Now it might look strange that these two people would come to the UK to visit Salisbury, of which, let’s be honest, most of us had never heard before the attack. Moreover, let’s be frank in that most of us would not go there two days in a row just because of inclement weather. Now as suspicious as this situation may seem, let us remember the rule of law and due process. Until these people are not only formerly charged, but also convicted beyond reasonable doubt of said attack, they should retain the presumption of innocence. It is up to the UK law enforcement and security services to prove their guilt.

The current situation where people are tried in the public opinion and media is one that any decent lawyer would be appalled by. There is no need to prove if one or the other party are truly guilty, all you need to do is to create doubt. Doubt, and generate support from the masses, this is then leveraged in politics. Just take a took at the false flag operations in favor of the first Gulf War. Where a young girl testified before the UN of the atrocities committed by Iraq in Kuwait, which in turn helped cement the reasoning behind the U.S. military’s Operation Desert Storm. Yet later it was shown that the girl, had never seen the conflict, and was in fact the daughter of the Kuwaiti ambassador to the UN. It is all about perception, once the damage is done it cannot be undone, reputations and lives cannot be rebuilt even after apologies or excuses.

Now as the pieces of the puzzle seem to be falling together, and seem to show that Russia was involved in the hit, doesn’t all of this seem too easy? For starters, the agents were open faced in the street, used credit cards and did not try to hide themselves. It all seems to simple… yet if you agree with Occam’s Razor theory (e.g. the simplest explanation is usually better), then indeed it would seem to be correct. However, in politics everything is almost never smooth. This situation merits an independent investigation, or as much as that is possible given the current world affairs. Let us see how this plays out, and observe how this situation plays into the mess that is the UK’s Brexit negotiations.

Read more:

"Skripal Poisoning Suspects Deny Involvement in Attack," by Max Seddon for the Financial Times. 

"Russian Media To Air Interviews with Skripal Suspects," by Henry Foy for the Financial Times. 

"Russians Accused of Poisoning Ex-Spy in England Claim to be Tourists," by James Marson for the Wall Street Journal. 

"Putin Says Accused Skripal Attackers Are Civilians," by Anatoly Kurmanaev and James Marson for the Wall Street Journal. 

Feel like commenting on our service or on what you just read? Want to make a suggestion? Got any complaints? Shoot us an email at [email protected]. Visit www.rossiyascan.com​ to signup!